大家
悠悠南山下
[主页]->[大家]->[悠悠南山下]->[中印衝突無必要!]
悠悠南山下
· 世界視野下的中港矛盾
·從邵逸夫逝世,回望东南亞中的香港
·為何中國不提早收回香港?
·鄧小平不願收回香港:一國兩制的本
·中華民國國小志大麻煩多
·香港六七暴動圖片
·為甚麼新加坡不可以是香港的出路?
·香港831以後,再看「昨日西藏」
·從三十年前的訪京團說起
·日本紀錄片:《污雲籠罩东方之珠》
· 北京會否血腥鎮壓「遮打革命」?
·梁特彈壓狂態畢露 佔中世代華麗登場
·越南22個組織支持香港雨傘革命
·香港鬧文革?謊話要秒殺
·我們都在創造歷史:香港佔中的思考
·期望青年人開創香港未來
·從滬港通和佔中再看中國金融大博奕
·滬港通所反映的思想盲點
·舊時香港成功,源於敢頂撞宗主國
·英密檔:倘中國违反联合聲明,英必出聲
·《港英時代》--重寫我城故事
·兩岸關係即將進入冷淡期!
·誰來代表香港?
·蝗圖騰
·北望,不如南看
·2047香港得唔得?
·香港不是殖民地?
·李登輝全文:揭開日台合作的新帷幕
·為了帝國的去殖民化
·郵筒的糾結
·為何「崛起」中國得不到台港年輕人的信任?
·失去什麼?
·何謂「天然獨」?台港新一代「去中國」思維的特徵
·台灣大選-無懸念與大懸念
·六七暴動四十五年祭
·獨立訴求的權利與民族自決無關(外一篇)
·香港自古以來不屬於共產黨
·香港的吉斯林派---答張翠容的疑惑
·「香港共同體」的形塑
·沖之鳥戰略位置與價值非常重要,真的嗎?
·「香港人」-- 新生身分認同的試煉
·不承認九二共識,WHA 還去得了嗎?
·旺角之夜 換了人間 香港社運的抗爭循環
·港獨是怎樣煉成的
·香港作為一個問題
·【本研解密】香港命運:被遺忘的美國
·諸獨根源皆中共
·本研解密:被遺忘的「自決派」——蘇偉澤
·《消失的檔案》:六七暴動真相重構
· 英國解密:六四後北京圖以基本法作籌碼換經援
·中共要摘掉台灣的「中華民國」?
·「六七暴動」,遺害至今
·歷史尋找本土──讀徐承恩《香港,鬱躁的家邦》
·六七暴動與恐怖主義
·避無可避:中國國族主義眼中的港獨
·為何英國不早給香港民主?
·從歷史角度看香港地位屬性
【 漫步東西徑 】
·一個外國人的北京初游記
·話說聖誕
·丹丹﹕ 七十七歲誕辰
·也談中國古詩押韻
·愧對英魂 --- 黄花崗九十年祭
·法國蒙塔基 --- 新中國的革命搖籃 !
·«悠悠南山下»嚴正聲明
·怎样理解“自古以来就是中国的领土”?
·革命者的年齡 --- 從东歐變天回望天安門六四
·夜郎为何不能自大?
·东歐民主潮流廿年後之回顧
·柏林墻倒塌圖片
·歷史的驚詫
·中國大陸落後問題的秦漢根源
·魁北克紀事
·臺灣东吳大學劉必榮教授談朝鮮半島局勢
·如何扔掉朝鲜这颗手雷
·中俄關系多有不測風雲
·尼克松訪華四十年
·觀視中國世界和西方世界
·中國對西藏的东方主義
·怨恨深植於亞洲
·莊則棟臨終字句與習近平的講話
·中国:一颗定时炸弹
·美國應否與中國平分權力?
·重溫四十年前的智利政變(圖)
·自由與宗教
·緬共紅二代:毛澤东一成錯九成功
·中國僑辦海外統戰的三大工程
·中越邊境槍擊案與維族越境者
·九段線、中華帝國的“新疆”
·走出這檯「中國大戲」
·勿忘六四
·六四25週年:越南官煤首次發聲批評
·六四25週年:法國報紙關注事件影響
·百年痴夢
·二次世界大戰紀錄片《啟示錄》
·朝鮮是個謎
·習近平v毛澤东. 大公報v大紀元
·东方歷史與西方概念
· 劉亞洲的甲午戰爭歷史觀
·成熟的學者可以怎麼讀書?
·中國社會政治文化結構:四層塔(外一篇)
[列出本栏目所有内容]
欢迎在此做广告
中印衝突無必要!

作者:劉山青 (香港)

   
   2017/7/31
   
   

   中印衝突是一重要事件。中國王毅外長在6月24,25日訪問了阿富汗和巴基斯坦;26日印度總理莫迪會見美國總統特朗普;同日發生了錫金段越過邊界線衝突。中國同時切斷了印度官方香客經乃堆拉山口赴藏朝聖的路段。
   
   大部份傳媒報導此事帶有政治目的,不符合“邏輯、細節和資料”的要求(註一)。沒有人問:中國為什麼要建這條道路?和不丹的角色。
   
   網誌上沒有文章討論此事。有些黃絲幻想印度打到北京,方便其建國;有些藍絲希望中共打鳩印度。總之,雙方都想打仗,冇想過戰爭的野蠻。
   
   印度外交部
   
   印度政府在6月30日的聲明(註二)很詳細。它指出:
   
   中國工程人員在不丹邊境強行搬走兩塊不丹基石;
   
   不丹提出抗議;
   
   印度人員一向有駐守那裡,要求中方停止行動;
   
   三方在2012年同意以聯絡小組方式商討那地段的現狀改變。
   
   印度不想激怒中方,它在7月17日的新聞發佈會用“鄰國”字眼,並表示沒有人員傷亡。
   
   不丹外交部
   
   不丹外交部聲稱(註三):中國的武裝人員在不丹土地興建一條軍事用行車道,通往不丹的軍營附近。不丹對此抗議。其聲明簡短,用詞不想得罪中國。
   
   On 16th June 2017, the Chinese Army started constructing a motorable road from Dokola in the Doklam area towards the Bhutan Army camp at Zompelri.
   
   中國外交部
   
   中方的立場(註四)是:“洞朗地區歷來屬於中國,不屬於不丹,與印度更沒有任何關係”。王毅的答覆是:“解決這個問題也很簡單,那就是,老老實實地退出去。”
   
   中方所持的是1890年《中英會議藏印條約》和1998年簽訂的《關於在中不(中國,不丹)邊境地區保持和平與安寧的協定》。它避談2012年的三方商議解決問題。
   
   two Governments had in 2012 reached agreement that the tri-junction boundary points between India, China and third countries will be finalized in consultation with the concerned countries
   
   第二大經濟實體
   
   習近平沙場閱兵(註5),表示「有能力打敗一切來犯之敵」。印度那裡敢來犯呢?印度國家安全顧問多瓦希望在出席金磚安代會期間與中國國務委員楊潔篪討論解決方法。
   
   在洞朗地區的道路施工沒有實質需要,若用來打仗則太少,平常用途則太多,而且那地方如一布袋,只能指向不丹的軍營,和“牧民每年均在此巡邏放牧”似乎無關。
   
   今次事件的目的只有宣示主權。但印度的邊防人員一向在那裡遊走,為何今天才進入中國領士呢?
   
   .In coordination with the RGOB, Indian personnel, who were present at general area Doka La
   
   習近平似乎喜歡用建築物做成既成事實,遠的有在具主權爭議的南沙群島「永暑礁」填海造陸,飛機跑道和停機坪;近的有今次事件。中國作為第二大經濟實體,本應待人以寬。主動挑起事端只會讓鄰國抱介心,不利一帶一路的進展。
   
   
   
   附錄
   註一
   
   東方
   
   印度軍隊試圖阻止中方人員進入所謂「印度領土」內,組起人牆阻擋;解放軍官兵則錄影現場情況,並拍攝照片。
   
   明報
   
   中國國防部發言人任國強26日晚表示,近日中方在洞朗地區進行道路施工時,遭到印軍越線阻攔。國防部又稱,中印邊界錫金段已由歷史條約劃定,中方修建上述道路完全是在自己領土上的主權行為,印方無權干涉。外交部發言人耿爽當晚亦稱,印度邊防人員在中印邊界錫金段越過邊界線進入中方境內,阻撓中國邊防部隊在洞朗地區的正常活動,中方已採取相應應對措施。
   
   美國之音
   
   截止記者發稿之時,印度官方尚未對中國的抗議作出回應。然而,印度媒體已經發表了大量為政府出謀劃策的文章,一些人要求以制裁中國產品的經濟手段回應中國的邊境“入侵”,也有人希望政府重新審視印度的“西藏政策”,更有人建議加強與美國、日本等國的軍事聯繫,希望印度購置或研發更強大的武器,同時做好邊境衝突進一步升級的準備。
   
   中時
   
   《不丹新聞網》的報導則表示,對於此次衝突,不丹官方一直沒有作出任何表態。
   
   環球網
   
   隨著北京將不惜“任何代價”保護國家利益,一場戰爭隱約來臨。印度也在加強戰備,但中國顯然在幾乎所有軍事領域都佔有優勢。美國軍控協會近期估計,中國的核武是印度的兩倍以上。若巴基斯坦再加入中國一方,就將演變為印度的災難。從目前情況來看,中國將在這場中印邊境爭端中堅決採取任何措施捍衛主權和領土完整。(作者珀林納·提克霍諾瓦,丁雨晴譯)
   
   香港01
   
   此次印度官員訪華,被看作是中印對峙以來,高層的一個溝通交流機制。但訪華能否達到印度期待的效果,仍有待觀察。目前中方並沒有透露哪位領導人將與其會面。印度方面希望中印雙方同時撤兵,最終實現邊境地區的穩定
   
   註二
   
   Ministry of External Affairs
   
   Government of India
   
   Recent Developments in Doklam Area
   
   June 30, 2017
   
   The Chinese made a statement on 26 June 2017 alleging that Indian border troops crossed the boundary line in the Sikkim sector of the China-India boundary and entered Chinese territory. This has been reiterated since then in other Chinese official briefings.
   
   The facts of the matter are as follows:
   
   i.On 16 June, a PLA construction party entered the Doklam area and attempted to construct a road. It is our understanding that a Royal Bhutan Army patrol attempted to dissuade them from this unilateral activity. The Ambassador of the Royal Government of Bhutan (RGOB) has publicly stated that it lodged a protest with the Chinese Government through their Embassy in New Delhi on 20 June.
   
   ii.Yesterday, the Foreign Ministry of Bhutan has also issued a statement underlining that the construction of the road inside Bhutanese territory is a direct violation of the 1988 and 1998 agreements between Bhutan and China and affects the process of demarcating the boundary between these two countries. They have urged a return to the status quo as before 16 June 2017.
   
   iii.In keeping with their tradition of maintaining close consultation on matters of mutual interest, RGOB and the Government of India have been in continuous contact through the unfolding of these developments.
   
   iv.In coordination with the RGOB, Indian personnel, who were present at general area Doka La, approached the Chinese construction party and urged them to desist from changing the status quo. These efforts continue.
   
   v.The matter has been under discussion between India and China at the diplomatic level in the Foreign Ministries since then, both in New Delhi and Beijing. It was also the subject of a Border Personnel Meeting at Nathu La on 20 June.
   
   India is deeply concerned at the recent Chinese actions and has conveyed to the Chinese Government that such construction would represent a significant change of status quo with serious security implications for India.
   
   In this context, the Indian side has underlined that the two Governments had in 2012 reached agreement that the tri-junction boundary points between India, China and third countries will be finalized in consultation with the concerned countries. Any attempt, therefore, to unilaterally determine tri-junction points is in violation of this understanding.
   
   Where the boundary in the Sikkim sector is concerned, India and China had reached an understanding also in 2012 reconfirming their mutual agreement on the "basis of the alignment”. Further discussions regarding finalization of the boundary have been taking place under the Special Representatives framework.
   
   It is essential that all parties concerned display utmost restraint and abide by their respective bilateral understandings not to change the status quo unilaterally. It is also important that the consensus reached between India and China through the Special Representatives process is scrupulously respected by both sides.
   
   India has consistently taken a positive approach to the settlement of its own boundary with China, along with the associated issue of the tri-junctions.
   
   India cherishes peace and tranquillity in the India-China border areas. It has not come easily. Both sides have worked hard to establish institutional framework to discuss all issues to ensure peace and tranquillity in the India-China border areas. India is committed to working with China to find peaceful resolution of all issues in the border areas through dialogue.
   
   New Delhi
   
   30 June 2017
   
   Official Spokesperson's response to a query about reports emanating from a neighbouring country about casualties of Indian soldiers in the Indian state of Sikkim due to military action with another country(link)
   
   July 17, 2017
   
   Responding to a query about reports emanating from a neighbouring country about casualties of Indian soldiers in the Indian state of Sikkim due to military action with another country, the Official Spokesperson said that such reports are utterly baseless, malicious and mischievous. No cognisance should be taken of them by responsible media.
   
   New Delhi
   
   17 July 2017
   
   註三
   
   Press Release
   
   June 29, 2017
   
   In view of the many queries raised recently in the media regarding the Bhutan – China boundary in the Doklam area the Ministry of Foreign Affairs would like to convey the following:

[下一页]
blog comments powered by Disqus

©Boxun News Network All Rights Reserved.
所有栏目和文章由作者或专栏管理员整理制作,均不代表博讯立场