盛雪文集
[主页]->[独立中文笔会]->[盛雪文集]->[RED SEA, BLACK GRIEF ]
盛雪文集
·藏人地震捐款为何被拒----且看中国驻多伦多总领事馆如何讲政治
·西藏真相
·寻找共同点——日内瓦汉藏会议:背景及缘起
·慈悲与尊重是汉藏关系的前途——温哥华汉藏论坛评述
·用了解、理解来化解误解——北美华文媒体访问达兰萨拉
·搭起漢藏民族相互瞭解的橋樑——谈多伦多汉藏论坛
·一路走来的脚印
·百位华人学者及民主人士与达赖喇嘛尊者对谈
·關注西藏命運,華人自我救贖
·透过藏人自焚的火焰(图)
·3. 10 請華人發出正義的呼聲
·暴政有期 大爱无疆
·暴政有期 大愛無疆
·西藏之痛 中國之恥 文明之殤
·在加拿大藏人于国会山举行的集会上演讲
·要求加拿大国会就西藏紧急局势举行听证会(请签名参与)
*********
中共国家恐怖主义
*********
·中共与国家恐怖主义(一)
·中共与国家恐怖主义(二)
·中共与国家恐怖主义(三)
·中共与国家恐怖主义(四)
**********
朱小华案独家报道
**********
·THE ZHU XIAOHUA CASE: A WINDOW INTO CHINESE HARDBALL POLITICS
·朱小华案系列报道(一)朱小华案开审,权力斗争升温
·朱小华案系列报道(二)朱小华庭上抗辩,推翻所有指控
·朱小华案系列报道(三)卷入权力斗争 朱小华家破人亡
·朱小华案系列报道(四)朱小华要求中央允境外记者采访
·朱小华案系列报道(五)朱镕基出访 朱小华遭殃
·朱小华案系列报道(六)朱案厮杀 港商垫底
·朱小华案系列报道(七)朱小华案将宣判,刑期十五年
·朱小华案系列报道(八)朱小华咆哮法庭
·江、朱各人手上一张牌――透视朱小华案、远华案
·原交通部副部长郑光迪案判决内幕
·朱熔基羽翼被翦──浅析朱小华案件
***********
政评和时评
***********
·知识界依附人格及选择困境
·江泽民访加与丢中国人的脸
·大厦将倾 硕鼠搬家-----谈中国贪官外逃
·共产劫富后的两个中国----透视中国的贫富悬殊
·致曹常青兼談民運
·新年感言
·我们是来自同一个国家么?
·张林被拘,亟需声援
·生命不能承受之重
·何处是乐园——福建偷渡者在加拿大
·世纪之交的中共对台湾政策及台湾的选择
·贾庆林与赖昌星案
·天人永隔之际--王炳章父亲病危唯一心愿见儿子一面
·一步之遥——平安或苦难
·王炳章父故世心愿未了天人永隔
·胡锦涛访加纪实
·万事似具备 遣返又成空--分析赖昌星遣返案的一波三折
·回应历史呼声终结共产暴政
·华妇溺杀患病女儿引争议
·熱比婭:維族的母親
·加拿大前後任總理為中國人權爭功勞
·正视中共在海外的间谍活动
·加拿大人对中国产品不放心
·加总理忙峰会:从北美到亚太
·为什么加中旅游协议总签不成
·奥运精神何在?──八十八岁母亲遥盼王炳章
·加拿大高官易丢“乌纱帽”
·为专制帮闲无异于助纣为虐
·北京奥运: 在普世价值透视下
·中文媒体忽悠华人
·香港已没有公民自由----记北京奥运香港行
·是食品还是毒品?----毒食品事件在加拿大继续发酵
·忽悠不了的沉默大多数
·罪证确凿也要当庭释放----中国留学生在加拿大造假案
·为失去话语权的人们发出声音
·2009年中国与世界的关系
·麻雀大战乌鸦
·盛雪谈加总理哈珀访问中国
·做人,还是做恐惧的华人?
·Being A Man or A Chinese in Fear?
·中国政府在赖昌星案上无法自圆其说
·《南都周刊》赖昌星逃亡这些年
·健康、正常、乐观、有尊严地活着
·盛雪披露远、朱两大案政治斗争黑幕 (图)
·盛雪评加法院下令扣押中国领事资产(图)
·盛雪谈平反法轮功
·张伟国 盛雪:陈希同朱小华保外就医与中南海权争
·盛雪:正在起死回生的中国
·盛雪演讲赖昌星远华案及反腐败
·盛雪披露远、朱两大案政治斗争黑幕 (图)
·賴昌星─中國特色的碩果
·中共霸權政治與加拿大民主大選
·中国民主日 告祭鲁之璠
·个体怯懦,群体嚣张(图)
·他們让卡城如此美麗
·从阴之道重回人间
[列出本栏目所有内容]
欢迎在此做广告
RED SEA, BLACK GRIEF

- Reflections on the Rally in Dundas Square
   
   
   by SHENG Xue
   

   RED SEA, BLACK GRIEF

   Oct.23, 2010; Toronton
   
   
   On the afternoon of March 29 at Dundas Square in Toronto, Canada, a sea of red, five-starred PRC flags and posters with patriotic slogans overwhelmed my eyes. It was a scene I had not witnessed for many years, (see attached photos), since the height of the Cultural Revolution in China when tens of thousands of young Red Guards were greeted by Chairman Mao in Tiananmen Square. People brandished the Red Flag excitedly, shouted "Long live China!", and loudly sang the Chinese national anthem "March of the Volunteers: when the Chinese nation was at its most dangerous time." Old overseas Chinese, new immigrants and visa students all shed tears.
   
   
   Meanwhile, the Chinese organizations' leaders calmly struggled to walk through the crowd. The rally's name was "Maintain the truth about Tibet. Safeguard the integrity of the motherland". They believed that the western media, in reports about the Tibet disturbances, discredited the Chinese government. They claimed that western societies are hostile to the Chinese and some of the populace in the West are stupid and ignorant. They argued that, in order to maintain national integrity, it was necessary for the Chinese government to deploy military force.
   
   This demonstration, called the 3.29 assembly, was widely reported by many Chinese media and websites. By general estimation, one- to 2,000 people attended. One organizers of the demonstration only provided a web name to the public: Black White. Because he left his email address for the demonstration, some people on the Internet accused this hot-blooded youth of operating a wife-swapping club in Toronto. This man, "black white" spoke loudly during the demonstration about Tibetan history. He fervently insisted that Tibet since ancient times is part of Chinese territory, and angrily protested the West's support of Tibet independence in order to split up China. He urged those at the demonstration to tell the truth about Tibet to the Canadian public and wake up the people of the West.
    Another speaker said during an interview that China's population includes 56 different ethnic groups, and everyone lives together in harmony, in a quite comfortable situation. There is no repression of any ethnic group or extermination of any culture. Before and after the demonstration, a local immigrant service website forum exploded with several thousand related posts. Many displayed anger towards western media and western society on the Tibet question.
   
   However, they - the demonstrators and spokespeople - have intentionally avoided some basic facts. Why did the Chinese government expel all reporters and media when the events of March 10 and 14 took place? Why didn't they let the media directly obtain the truth, and report the complete picture of the events? And why don't these young students and patriotic overseas Chinese use their energy to organize demonstrations to tell the world the truth about Tibet. They live thousands of miles away, and the overwhelming majority of them have never been to Tibet and possibly don't know a single Tibetan.
   
   For over 50 years, within China, have people been able to freely and openly discuss Tibet? Do the Chinese have normal channels of communication to understand Tibet, its history and the present situation?
   
   In Mainland China, do the Han-Chinese and the Tibetans have the right to assemble in public to express demands like they do in Canada? They have lived their lives in a society where news media are controlled, and correspondence is blocked. So how is it possible that, under these circumstances, they can better grasp the truth about Tibet than we can in a society where the flow of information is unimpeded, where there is freedom of speech, freedom to do research?
   
   Why, indeed, do the Tibetan lamas need large-scale demonstrations to deliver their petitions? Why did their peaceful petitions and assemblies require armed suppression which deteriorated into violent disturbance?
   
   Moreover, who is this "western media"? Who are they? In the West, each outlet of media has its own, individual political stand. The US has the Wall Street Journal with a relatively right-wing standpoint. They also have "the New York Times" with a more liberal stance and a comparatively left-wing perspective. Even extreme-left Maoist magazines that kiss Jiang Qing (Madame Mao) are permitted. In Canada we also read the People's Daily's overseas edition and see China's Central Committee Television (CCTV) programs without censorship.
   
   Western media are multi-faceted with many bosses, and are basically all privately owned. In western nations, unlike China, a government-dominated media monopoly, such as that of the CPC, is impossible. In China, most newspapers, magazines, radio and television are controlled by the Party and the government.
   
   Every media outlet can make mistakes, and, in western nations, their biases can result in big mistakes. The mistakes are often caused by competition among the media outlets, but competition also acts as a restraint resulting in public vigilance to correct them. Those who aren't truthful and objective can be defeated through competition. People don't buy their products, and they go out of business. Western media are not dominated by a unified political influence or a special-interest group. Western media, while skeptical and vigilant about those in power in government and in society, are at the same time being scrutinized by the people.
   
   Unlike China's media, western media cannot be forced to be the mouthpiece of a political party or the megaphone for a government. At times when politics demands it the Chinese collectively create lies. This monopoly of false news, without any long-term surveillance, brings disaster on the nation and people. The anti-right campaign, the great famine, and the Cultural Revolution are some of the most obvious examples.
   
   The dauntless spirit of these hot-blooded, indignant Chinese youths who want to use the "truth" to "awaken the western populace", reminds one of the 60s when the young Red Guards wanted to plant the red five-starred flag all over the world to liberate the world's population. They act as if, over the last 50 years, China was a democracy, Chinese citizens could speak freely, and China was a society where they lived incomparably happy lives. On the other hand, the entire western world is portrayed as evil and despotic. In coming to Canada, they shoulder the huge responsibility to liberate the local people from an information blockade, opinion control and illiteracy. What a joke!
   
   If 80 million people who died under Chinese Communist Party rule had the right to speak, they would send out a roar that would certainly instill fear in this group of brave warriors and scatter them from the Square. However, these protesters whose blood boiled in response to their own accomplishment are obviously not interested in taking advantage of the opportunity of a society where information flows freely. They don't know, and don't want to know, the true history of Tibet.
   
   The Tibetan uprising started as a result of Tibetans inside and outside of Tibet commemorating the 50th anniversary of the uprising on March 10.
   
   On 10 March, 1959, Tibetans rose up in revolt against Chinese Communist Party rule. The CPC army suppressed the revolt, killing 80,000 Tibetans, and the 14th Dalai Lama and 100,000 Tibetans took refuge in India. More than 6,000 Tibetan temples were nearly all destroyed during the Cultural Revolution. According to the deceased Punchen Lama's memoirs, of the original more than 600,000 Buddhist lamas, 110,000 were persecuted and killed, and 250,000 people were compelled to return to secular life.
   
   In 1989, three months before the Chinese Communist Party carried out the June 4th suppression in Beijing, the CCP used the PLA to suppress Tibetan demonstrations in Lhasa. During this event the Tibetan death and injury toll was serious, and more than 3,000 Tibetans were arrested.

[下一页]

©Boxun News Network All Rights Reserved.
所有栏目和文章由作者或专栏管理员整理制作,均不代表博讯立场