百家争鸣
[发表评论] [查看此文评论]    郭国汀律师专栏
[主页]->[百家争鸣]->[郭国汀律师专栏]->[诉江泽民案美国依据国际法的义务:是对公共安全的危胁还是种族灭绝?]
郭国汀律师专栏
·敬请胡锦涛先生立即制止下属恶意疯狂攻击南郭之电脑
·"六四领袖去死吧!"及 " 逢共必反、逢华必反"?!
·草根吾友欲往何处去?
·真实的陈泱潮故事
·陈泱潮自传之二
·强烈推荐国人必读之最佳政论文
·答小溪先生质疑
·驳斥草虾兼与草根商榷!
·伟大的中国文化复兴宣言 郭国汀
·关于宣讲人权公约基金申请推荐函
·必须立即终止反动透顶的行政官员任命制
·自由中国论坛的不锈钢老鼠到底是什么角色?
·关注李宇宙的命运
***(43)中国民主运动的思想、理论与实践
·中国争人权言论表达自由权的先驱者与英雄名录
·民主革命论 陈泱潮
·《特权论的》精髓——对共产专制特权制度的深刻致命批判
·特权论的精髓——对共产专制特权制度的深刻致命批判 郭国汀
·枭雄黑道乱世的一百年!郭国汀
·论无产阶级民主制度下的两党制
·陈泱潮评胡锦涛
·陈泱潮论江泽民
·我为什么特别推崇陈泱潮先生的思想理论?
·天才论/郭国汀
·彻底揭露批判中共极权专制流氓暴政本质的奇书
·极权专制暴政的根源/郭国汀
·共产极权专制暴政的典型特征——简评陈泱潮的《特权论》
·论共产极权专制政权的本质——三评陈泱潮天才著作《特权论》
·何谓“无产阶级专政”
·陈泱潮论马克思主义的无产阶级专政 郭国汀
·论初级无产阶级专政 /新南郭点评
·论高级无产阶级专政 郭国汀
·中国何往?——政治思想论战书 /新南郭
·陈泱潮论改良主义/郭国汀
·文化大革命是中国民主革命的序幕 郭国汀
·陈泱潮妙评邓小平的“瞎猫屠夫理论” 郭国汀
·陈泱潮精评毛泽东 郭国汀
·论共产党官僚垄断特权阶级 郭国汀
·共产党官员为什么普遍腐化堕落?郭国汀
·“三个代表”是个什么玩意? 郭国汀
·对抗性的社会基本矛盾 郭国汀
·为何中共官员多具有奴隶主和奴仆的双重人格? 郭国汀
·共产专制特权等级制 郭国汀
·人民“公仆”是如何变成骑在人民头上作威作福的老爷的? 郭国汀
·神化首要分子神化党与邪教 郭国汀
·宗教政治与人权灵本主义 郭国汀
·陈尔晋论今日中国社会主要矛盾及前途与命运
·陈泱潮先生在当代中国思想史上的地位 作者:曾节明
***(44)反中共极权专制暴政争自由宪政人权民主绝食抗暴民权运动
·南郭致涵习近平先生
·郭律师致高智晟女儿格格的公开信
·福布斯报导高智晟失踪事件
·胡锦涛必须对高智晟受酷刑负直接罪责!
·郭国汀 高智晟律师为何不发声?
·我眼中的高智晟
·郭国汀 从我的经历看中共当局诽谤高智晟的下流
·所谓高智晟公开声明及悔罪书肯定是伪造的
·真正的中国人的伟大怒吼!
·加拿大著名人权律师安世立支持声援全球绝食抗暴的声明
·闻律师英雄高智晟再遇车祸有感 郭国汀
·呼吁全球万人同步大绝食宣言
·全球接力绝食抗暴运动的伟大意义 郭国汀
·郭国汀声援和平抗暴 呼吁抛弃中共
·中国律师界应全力声援高智晟
·专家剖析高智晟煽动颠覆国家政权案
·抓捕关押高智晟的整个过程都是违法的/郭国汀
·中共迫害高智晟亲人丧心病狂,中共党魁胡锦涛难辞其咎
·绝食维权抗暴日记
·郭国汀 漠视大陆维权是一种自杀行为
·英雄伟人与超人高智晟
·告全体中国律师及法律人书----闻高智晟被秘密绑架感言
·郭国汀: 高智晟遭秘密绑架可能成为中共灭亡的导火索
·给真正的中国女人的公开信
·郭国汀:驳刘荻的非理性投射说
·决不与中共专制暴政同流合污--------第29个全球接力绝食抗暴日记 郭国汀
·一部见证当代中国社会现实的伟大纪实作品--序高智晟《中国民间企业维权第一案》
·郭国汀呼吁国际重视高智晟妻儿的遭遇
·将接力绝食抗暴运动进行至最后胜利
·我为中华律师英雄杨在新喝彩 郭国汀
·郭国汀向老戚致敬
·万众一心,众志成城——全球万人同步绝食抗暴日记 郭国汀
·责令中共当局立即无条件释放兰州大学学生刘西峰!郭国汀
·加拿大著名人权律师ANSLEY支持声援全球绝食抗暴运动的声明
·郭国汀:中国律师应当向高智晟,浦志强律师学习!
***(45)人权研究
***中国人权律师基金会
·郭国汀推荐黄金秋竞选[第三届中国自由文化运动政论奖]推荐函
·郭国汀提名陈泱潮为2009中国自由文化奖之文化成就奖获奖候选人
·郭国汀提名张博树为2009中国自由文化奖之法学奖获奖候选人
·推荐郭国汀先生参选2009年台湾民主人权奖书
·letter of recommendation of Guoting for 2008 Asia Democracy and Human Rights Award
·提名郭國汀律師作為[第三屆亞洲民主與人權獎]候選人的推薦函
·支持郭国汀律师负责组建中国人权律师基金会
·第二届《中国自由文化奖》评奖程序的修改建议
·郭国汀提名张鉴康律师作为第二届自由文化奖之人权奖候选人
[列出本栏目所有内容]
欢迎在此做广告
诉江泽民案美国依据国际法的义务:是对公共安全的危胁还是种族灭绝?


   
   诉江泽民案美国依据国际法的义务:是对公共安全的危胁还是种族灭绝?
   
   南郭点评:2002年10月法轮功在美国联邦法院依据《外国人侵权索赔法》(the Alien Tort Claims Act (ATCA).对江泽民提起侵权之诉,约36位国会议员支持法轮功之诉,但2003年9月地区法院以江系国家主席享有外国元首豁免权为由驳回了起诉。本案主要涉及中共迫害镇压法轮功是否构成种族灭绝?是否存在制度性的迫害?法轮功是否宗教?是否邪教?什么情况下元首无权享受豁免?

   
   作者系迈阿密大学经济学院副教授,总体上说,由于他是局外人,持论较客观,但由于他对法轮功实际情况并不十分了解,且由于语言文化等差异,使其不易辩别真假,特别是将中共精至包装出口转内销式的谎言当真,导致文中错误不少.例如,他对中国实际的人权状况并不真正了解,故对中共统治下的人权所谓进步的评价明显过高;SARS期间,中共编造有法轮功学员故意染上SARS到处传染给别人以制造动乱,而作者对中共的谎言未能识别而采信;作者在文中引称:After this event, a Hong Kong news source quoted Mr. Li Hongzhi as stating, "At long last, there are Falun Gong practitioners who are willing to step forward and sacrifice their lives for the purpose of advocating the Fa [way]. "[84],其实,中共CCTV在2001年1月29日晚播出所谓天安门自焚伪案时,曾指控是李洪志指挥自焚,后来改称李洪志对有学员自焚捍卫法轮功很高兴,“终于有人愿意为了大法而牺牲了”。该所谓香港媒体引证李洪志先生的说法,纯属中共编造的谎言。中共旨在掩盖自已导演的自焚伪案罪孽以栽赃法轮功,煽动民众仇恨法轮功。
   
   再者,转法轮谈到辟谷时仅是谈修炼界的一种现象,而非法轮功的修炼方法,并明确说明该法门不讲辟谷;大量学员因被非法关押而绝食抗议受中共强制灌食致死,中共却胡编说学员辟谷或自杀! 此外,转法轮得及的遥视,宿命通等功能,并非如作者以为李洪志先生给学员均下上了这些功能。即使在实修中有人如有升华可能出现这些功能时,李先生也给封锁起来,因为不能干扰常人社会或是用功能做一些似好实坏的事。
   
   无论如何,作者从国际法与美国法及判例详尽分析了本案涉及的众多法律问题,作了较有说服力的论证.江氏侥幸逃避法律制裁,主因乃是中共向布什政府施加了巨大压力,此外证据亦不够充分,如果中国本土律师配合调查取证.证实中共大规模残暴镇压法轮功是制度性的,而且并非针对法轮功学员的违法犯罪行为更非为所谓公共安全,而是针对学员的信仰,特别是大规模活体盗卖法轮功学员人体器官,江胡恐怕皆将永久性面临国际法的追诉.本文值得所有关心法轮功的法律人精读.
   
   
   
   2009年3月15日第158个反中共极权专制暴政争自由人权民主绝食争权抗暴运动日
   
诉江泽民案美国依据国际法的义务:是对公共安全的危胁还是种族灭绝?

   
   宗教信仰自由是一项基本人权
   
   
   
   United States Obligations under International Law and the Falun Gong v. Jiang Zemin Lawsuit: A Justified Reaction to a Threat to Public Security or Genocide ? You Decide
   
   
   
   By Robert Bejesky*
   
   
   
    Conflicting public perceptions of the Falun Gong: "Falun Gong is a notorious, evil cult built on a pack of lies and deceptive heretical fallacies. It controls the mind[s] of its practitioners and manipulates them spiritually."[1]
   
    "Falun Gong is a meditation system that teaches truthfulness, compassion and tolerance. It emphasizes the cultivation of one's heart and mind, and has five sets of gentle physical movements that harmonize the body with the outside universe."[2] "Similar to yoga and Tai-chi, it is designed to improve health and reduce stress."[3]
   
    Falun Gong teachings and member actions have caused over 1,700 deaths.[4] This includes hundreds of member suicides.[5] 748 Falun Gong members have died at the hand of government authorities while in police or administrative custody.[6]
   
    Falun Gong teachings drove a member to murder 17 innocent people by poison.[7] Tens of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners have been detained in Chinese administrative detention facilities to force them to renounce their spiritua beliefs.[8] Torture is commonplace in these facilities.[9]
   
   
   
    TABLE OF CONTENTS
   
   
   
    1. INTRO DU CTION ............................................................................. 297
   
    II. THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT'S TREATMENT OF FALUN G O N G ..... 299
   
    A. Chinese Government and Jiang Zemin v. Falun Gong ...... 299
   
    1. History of Falun Gong .................................................... 299
   
    2. Stage One ......................................................................... 301
   
    3. Stage Two ......................................................................... 302
   
    4. Stage Three and the Clash with the Chinese
   
    Government ..................................................................... 304
   
    III. HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES ............................................................. 308
   
    A . Introduction ............................................................................ 308
   
    B. Potential Human Rights Violations ..................................... 310
   
    1. Banning Falun Gong: Cultural and Government
   
    Relativism ........................................................................ 310
   
    2. Government and Populace Positions Regarding
   
    Falun Gong ...................................................................... 315
   
    3. Detention of Members ................................................... 317
   
    4. Criminal Law Offenses and Convictions ...................... 319
   
    5. R E T L ................................................................................ 320
   
    6. Summary .......................................................................... 323
   
    IV. GENOCIDE AND UNIVERSAL CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY.. 324
   
    A. The International Legal Framework that Prohibits Genocide ………..324
   
    B. Applying International Law that Prohibits Genocide to
   
    the Falun Gong Crackdown ................................................. 326
   
    1. Introduction ..................................................................... 326
   
    2. Is Falun Gong a Religion? ............................................. 327
   
    3. Is Falun Gong a "Cult"? ................................................. 330
   
    4. To Eliminate "in Whole or in Part" ................... 333
   
    C. Summary of Cited Twentieth Century Atrocities ................ 334
   
    V. JURISDICTION FOR UNIVERSAL JURISDICTION CRIMES
   
    AND HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS ............................................ 335
   
    A. The International Relations Debacle ................................... 335
   
    1. Civil Jurisdiction .............................................................. 337
   
    2. Applying Precedent and Comity to the Falun Gong
   
    Case ................................................................................... 338
   
    V I. CONCLUSION ................................................................................. 339
   
   
   
    I. INTRODUCTION
   
   
   
    According to some media sources and groups, Falun Gong is a peaceful meditation group that has been viciously attacked by the Chinese government. According to the Chinese government, many Falun Gong practitioners are the spawn of a heretical cult leader, and the group collectively could raze Chinese society if given the opportunity to evangelize. On July 22, 1999, the Chinese government marked Falun Gong as an "evil cult," (no only after September marked it as evil cult) banned it, organized a crackdown movement that included a campaign to garner public support for the crackdown, and implemented a policy conceived to "re-educate" Falun Gong members to reverse the group's indoctrination.[10]
   
   
   
    The events involving Falun Gong over the past four years in China have knocked at the door of the U.S. judicial system. Falun Gong filed a lawsuit in October 2002 against former Chinese leader Jiang Zemin in federal court for acts of genocide and other human rights violations pursuant to the jurisdiction of the Alien Tort Claims Act (ATCA).[11] More than three dozen members of Congress filed an amicus curiae brief in support of Falun Gong, while the Bush Administration filed an amicus curiae brief to dismiss the case.[12] The lawsuit was dismissed in September 2003 by the U.S. district court, which held that Jiang Zemin's head-of-state immunity barred the lawsuit.[13] The dispute, however, seems far from over.[14] This article endeavors to impartially present the merits of the case by navigating the highly propagandized media positions and encourages the reader to draw his or her own conclusions regarding the claims.

[下一页]

©Boxun News Network All Rights Reserved.
所有栏目和文章由作者或专栏管理员整理制作,均不代表博讯立场