大家
[发表评论] [查看此文评论]    郭国汀律师专栏
[主页]->[大家]->[郭国汀律师专栏]->[New York Time A Mild Shanghai Lawyer and His Accidental Crusade]
郭国汀律师专栏
·最高法院无理拖宕九年拒不下判再审案代理词
·外贸代理合同争议案再审申请书
·国际货物买卖结算争议案代理词
·外贸代理合同争议案上诉审代理词
·进出口外贸代理争议案初步法律意见书
***(6)典型刑事及重大刑事案
·为赖昌星遗返案我的宣誓证词
·公、检、党政联合办案与党的领导
·“反革命恶霸”案刑事申诉状
·马翔非法为境外提供国家秘密罪刑事上诉状
·全国首例法官告律师名誉侵权争议案
·公安刑警刑讯逼供致死人命案辩护词
·王水珍“寻衅滋事”案辩护词
·王水珍“寻衅兹事”案刑事上诉状
·王水珍寻衅滋事案上海市闸北区人民法院刑事判决书
·中共法院被阉割成不伦不类的东西的铁证
·非法侵入他人住宅罪辩护词
·关于张赫监视居住死亡事件的法律意见书
·关于公安强行介入经济纠纷拘留无辜公民做人质逼债的紧急呈阅件
·奸淫幼女案辩护词
·受贿案辩护词
·为境外非法提供国家秘密案刑事上诉状
·谢某受贿案刑事申诉状
·张春“双规”屈打成召刑事申诉状
***(7)经典商事合同民事案
·一起重大善意取得争议案重审代理词
·网络电子邮件名誉侵权争议案
·外观专利设计争议案代理词
·福建省首例著作权争议案代理词
·果园承包合同纠纷案代理词
·借贷纠纷上诉案代理词
·借款纠纷上诉案代理词
·“天下第一剑”商标侵权争议案代理词
·析产争议案代理词
·不当得利争议案起诉状
·不当得利争议一审代理词
·不当得利争议案上诉状
·不当得利争议案上诉状
·不当得利重审案代理词
·出租车乘客伤害应向谁索赔?
·服务合同争议案代理词
·“权利质押借款合同”争议案代理词
·涉外商品房屋买卖合同质品争议案代理词
·抚恤金争议案上诉审代理词
·劳动争议(运钞车被劫)争议仲裁代理词
·航空货运代理合同争议案答辩状
·航空货运代理合同争议案代理词之二
·航空货运代理合同争议案代理词
·运输费争议案代理词
·租赁合同争议案代理词
·房屋预售合同(债权转让)争议案代理词
***(8)海事海商名案要案
·“国鸿”轮光船租赁合同争议仲裁案代理词
·船舶碰撞侵权争议案代理词
·Ocean Glory轮碰撞争议案代理词
·海上货运保险合同(代位权)争议案代理词
·安泰轮船舶保险合同上诉案情代理词
·安泰轮船舶保险合同争议上诉审代理词(正)
·翻船货损代位追偿案初步法律意见
·扣押船舶申请书
·海上货运合同争议案初步法律意见
·船舶保险合同争议案上诉状 郭国汀
·安泰轮船舶保险合同争议案代理词
·船舶买卖合同争议上诉案代理词/郭国汀
·造船合同争议案上诉审代理词/郭国汀
·安泰轮船舶保险合同争议案上诉答辩状/郭国汀
·安泰轮船舶保险合同争议上诉审代理词/郭国汀
·海上货物运输货损争议案代理词/郭国汀
·海上货物运输运费争议案代理词/郭国汀
·无单放货争议案上诉代理词/郭国汀
·新世纪轮船舶保险合同争议上诉案代理词/郭国汀
·航空货运代理合同争议案代理词/郭国汀
·海上货运合同争议案代理词/郭国汀
·船舶碰撞争议案代理词/郭国汀
·安泰轮船舶保险合同争议案代理词/郭国汀
·海上货运货损代位追偿案代理词/郭国汀
·越权放行提单争议案代理词/郭国汀
·海上货物运输运费争议案代理词/郭国汀
·放行提单侵权争议听证代理意见书
·诉前还船海事强制令申请书/郭国汀
·渔业船舶碰撞侵权争议案代理词/郭国汀
·关于“8•5”油污染事故损害赔偿的初步法律意见/郭国汀
·关于新世纪轮船舶保险合同纠纷上诉案代理词之二
·强制执行令复议申请书/郭国汀
·诉前海事强制令听证代理意见书/郭国汀
·诉前还船海事强制令申请书/郭国汀
·沉船货损索赔争议案重审代理词/郭国汀
·关于进口货物货方要求签发两套提单有何风险的法律意见/郭国汀
·进口鱼粉自燃货损争议案代理词/郭国汀
·海上货物运输货损争议案起诉状/郭国汀
·清风洲轮货损争议案代理词/郭国汀
·航空货运运费争议案析/郭国汀
·上海亚通股份有限公司不服行政行为纠纷案代理词/郭国汀
·货代合同争议案上诉答辩状/郭国汀
·船舶保险合同争议上诉状/郭国汀
[列出本栏目所有内容]
欢迎在此做广告
New York Time A Mild Shanghai Lawyer and His Accidental Crusade

A Mild Shanghai Lawyer and His Accidental Crusade
   By HOWARD W. FRENCH
   Published: September 18, 2004 new york time
   SHANGHAI
   WHEN Guo Guoting pauses to think about the course his life has taken, it is the jagged lines, the result of a series of accidents, that impress him most.

   As a college student, he set his sights on physics, but his score on the graduate study exam betrayed him, so he ended up studying law instead.
   
   After graduation from law school, he was sent by the government to be a judge in Fujian Province. Upon arriving there, he was told that what the courts really needed was lawyers, so Mr. Guo complied and went into practice.
   Mr. Guo eventually settled in Shanghai, where he became established in shipping law. Here, his life was altered once again by events more unexpected than anything that had come before. His troubles began when he heard about a law school classmate who had been jailed for taking on the Shanghai authorities over the sudden eviction of neighborhoods marked for real estate development.
   The classmate, Zheng Enchong, had not been a close friend. Mr. Guo said he barely recalled him, in fact. But hearing the man had been jailed - after a five-hour secret trial - for filing hundreds of lawsuits on behalf of dispossessed Shanghai residents, and recognizing that no other lawyers would represent him for fear of being blacklisted, or worse, Mr. Guo said he felt compelled to step forward.
   "I wasn't being a hero," said Mr. Guo, 46, a short, affable man previously known by his colleagues more for his strong work ethic and modesty than for crusading. "I was doing the right thing."
   The rest, as they say, is history, personal history of the brutal, hard-knock variety commonplace in China, a place that may be changing rapidly in many ways but where one old rule endures: you can't fight City Hall.
   SINCE he was a young man, Mr. Guo said, he has dreamed of a quiet life in a small village somewhere, a life in the shadows of a mountain in a small house close enough to a river or brook to hear the gurgling flow of the water from his study.
   "I don't like arguments," he said, chuckling at himself, during a interview in a restaurant atop a skyscraper affording one of the best views of this city's skyline. "I don't even enjoy social intercourse so much, to tell the truth. My kind of personality really isn't suited for being a lawyer."
   For his efforts to defend a friend and principle, Mr. Guo has recently been driven from the law, deprived of a livelihood after most of his paying clientele was scared away, but not before adding his name to a long and growing roll of accidental activists, people driven to do something in their own immediate spheres by the intolerable injustices they encounter in everyday life.
   One of those is the dispossession of the powerless, which has long been the dirty little secret behind much of China's extraordinary urban development. Local authorities have been able to condemn buildings and clear land without so much as a hearing, and distribute the land to developers in murky, no-bid sweetheart deals.
   In Shanghai, a fantasyland of skyscrapers today in a city where tall buildings scarcely existed only 15 years ago, these stories have a particularly breathtaking quality to them. In some instances, residents of old properties in choice areas of the city have been summoned to the police station only to return and find their houses demolished.
   Mr. Zheng had angered local officials by filing a series of lawsuits and court motions designed to at least slow the land expropriations.
   In a touch that could have been borrowed from Kafka, the city government accused Mr. Zheng of violating security laws for faxing public documents about a real estate case to a human rights group in the United States.
   That was when Mr. Guo took up his case, filing an appeal for his schoolmate in the Shanghai High People's Court. Immediately, he said, there were warnings to stop, subtle at first, but then increasingly menacing. Then his main business, representing maritime shippers, began to fall off, his clients frightened away. "The authorities called me in 18 times to tell me to abandon this case," he said. "It's not a legal matter, it's a political matter, they'd say.
   "Finally, a midlevel cadre warned me, 'If you pursue this case any further, whatever comes of it will be entirely your own responsibility.'
   A Mild Shanghai Lawyer and His Accidental Crusade
   Published: September 18, 2004
    Gao Feng/Imagine China, for The New York Times
   "I believe that, one case at a time, we can change the legal system.
   "Other city officials approached me privately to say they personally didn't want to do this to me," said Mr. Guo, whose hands stay busy with his cellphone and cigarettes as he speaks. "It is the people behind the scenes, the higher ups who have decided this. This is how things work in China, the powerful people remain invisible, but there will always be mid-level cadres who are willing to tell you what is happening."
   Despite the mounting trouble, Mr. Guo said he had given blunt advice to his classmate, Mr. Zheng. "I told him that you have a choice," he said. "If you drop the matter and admit that you were wrong, you can go free. But if you do that, nobody will respect you."
   Mr. Zheng remained resolute, but his appeal was ultimately rejected.
   Mr. Guo's feelings about social justice developed only gradually. Slowly, in the course of his practice, activism bit him, he says, as he began exchanging ideas with other lawyers about how to improve the workings of China's rickety legal system and to protect individual rights. Encouraged by colleagues, Mr. Guo eventually began posting his thoughts on legal issues on the Internet. He emerged as a prominent figure in local law circles, someone looked up to and regarded with awe by younger lawyers.
   "Most Chinese lawyers just want to make money, to become rich," Mr. Guo said in an initial interview some weeks ago, sounding almost like a happy warrior. "I want to make money, too, but as a man, I don't want to forget my purpose, or forget higher ideals. I believe that, one case at a time we can change the legal system."
   SEEN again more recently, after the news that Mr. Zheng's appeal had been denied, the lawyer seemed like a different man, defeated, even depressed. Another case he had taken on, an even more radical challenge to the system, was now headed to a foreordained defeat. It was a defense of a citizen's rights under the Constitution to try to form an independent political party.
   Speaking at a teahouse, dressed casually in short sleeves, Mr. Guo somberly announced he was quitting the law. He had been spending his own money to argue cases like these and had not had any income for the last four months, and could not support his family.
   The political case had meaning for him because he saw some value in putting his arguments on the Internet. "It is the demand of the people and of the times to end one-party rule and to free the press," he wrote in his bold summation. The authorities, however, had already blocked Mr. Guo's writings from the legal Web sites he once used.
   "I always thought things would gradually get better," Mr. Guo said, explaining how things had come to this pass. "I now realize how dark our society is, and our legal system is just the same."
   Fighting with city hall in Shanghai - and losing Published in International HeraldTribune - Indexed on Sep 17, 2004 Relevance: SHANGHAI When Guo Guoting pauses tothink about the course his life has taken, it is the jagged lines, the results ... shanghai.newstrove.com/ - 101k
   Fujian Post
   ... Fighting with city hall in Shanghai - and losing When Guo Guoting pauses to thinkabout the course his life has taken, it is the jagged lines, the results of a seriesof accidents, that impress him most.As a college student, he set his sights ... www.fujianpost.com/ - 101k
   IHT: Asia/Pacific
   ... Australia: News.com.au. A Special Section for Expats. AT HOME ABROAD. Fighting withcity hall in Shanghai - and losing. When Guo Guoting pauses to think about the coursehis life has taken, it is the jagged lines that impress him most.Diplomat ...www.kniff.de/cgi-bin/cgiproxy/nph-proxy.cgi/ 010110A/http/www.iht.com/asia.html -

[下一页]

©Boxun News Network All Rights Reserved.
所有栏目和文章由作者或专栏管理员整理制作,均不代表博讯立场